The International Society for Military Ethics in Europe

 

Time flies quickly : what has EuroISME reached after 10 years, where shall EuroISME go in the next 10 years?

 

 anniversary 10 paris berlin

On June 16 and 17, 2011, the members and friends of the International Society for Military Ethics (ISME) met for the first time in Europe, after all previous meetings since 2005 had taken place in the USA. With the Ecole Militaire in the middle of Paris, one of the most prestigious conference venues ever had been elected for the event.

In view of the progressive integration of troops from former Warsaw Pact states into multinational European armed forces structures and of regular deployments within the framework of EU peace missions, the European experts faced the urgent demand for an independent EuroISME association in order to better adapt their work to the specific European approach for analysis and further development of the military ethical fundamentals.

After clarifying the legal and financial framework, the founding decision was taken during this Paris conference.

Since then - thanks to intensive work of the Board of Directors and thanks to the idealistic commitment of all members - EuroISME has been widely recognized as an outstanding European forum for the discussion and exchange of ideas on the professional responsibility of soldiers and on military ethical thinking

The annual conferences, which are held in cooperation with renowned institutions and at attractive conference venues, are attended by high-ranking experts from all over the world. They are "beacon events" which are usefully supplemented by numerous initiatives and other thematically focused meetings.

Unfortunately we could not hold the 10th Annual Meeting 2020 in Berlin as originally planned and celebrate there the anniversary duely with EuroISMEs usual formal dinner! The COVID pandemic first forced us to postpone and then to conduct the conference 100% virtual ...

However, the pandemic was (and is) also a clear warning about rapidly changing conditions and new challenges in the implementation of security and peace - not only for our continent! The pertinent issue of values ​​and virtues, of principles and norms of behavior for the creation of a common culture of responsibility and ethical thinking is particularly acute today!

The European armed forces, but also "security forces" in a wider sense, are confronted with new types of operations and methods of deployment. The drifting apart of traditional forms and structures of society leads to diverse conflicts in Europe and on its periphery, which cannot be overcome with the original (Clausewitzian) concept of "war as the continuation of politics by other means". The “Just Peace” is becoming more and more difficult to establish, the “Just War” is no longer an adequate ethical compass on the way to there.

This question should not wait to be tackled till the next annual conference in Budapest in 2022: within EuroISME there has been and is - from the very beginning - competition between the various approaches for a common European leadership culture in the armed forces ! These tensions must be endured and worked up! For this, too, EuroISME was founded 10 years ago as an independent association ... and will work even more energetically for its goals over the next 10 years!

Discuss it with us in the forum:

 

Log in to comment

Prof. Dr. Thomas R. Elssner's Avatar
Prof. Dr. Thomas R. Elssner replied the topic: #2 4 months 1 week ago
Als Vizepräsident von EuroISME hätte ich anläßlich unserer "Online-Konferenz 2021" gerne etwas dazu gesagt!
Sehen Sie hier dazu meinen  Videobeitrag , der vom "Programm-Komitee" leider nicht übernommen wurde...
Den Vortragstext mit (Deepl)Übersetzung ins Englische können Sie hier als PdF herunterladen  Wohlgemerkt : es geht dabei absolut nicht um Deutsch oder Französisch als Arbeitssprache bei unseren Tagungen, sondern um die Analyse von Grundlagen und Konzepten in allen relevanten Wissenschaftssprachen für einen "gemeinsamen europäischen Ansatz" in der Militärethik!
Ich freue mich auf Ihre Kommentare !
Prof. Dr. Thomas R. Elssner's Avatar
Prof. Dr. Thomas R. Elssner replied the topic: #3 4 months 5 days ago
On the occasion of our "Online Conference 2021" and as a Vice President of EuroISME, I would have liked to say something about this question !
You can see my preregistered video here, which was unfortunately not taken by the "Program Committee" ...
Here you can also download the text as a PdF file.
Mind you: it is absolutely not about German or French as the working languages at our conferences, but about the analysis of fundamentals and concepts in all relevant scientific languages for a "common European approach" in military ethics!
I am looking forward to read your comments !
Eric Germain's Avatar
Eric Germain replied the topic: #4 3 months 3 weeks ago
 [justify]"Vom Profil her wird EuroISME noch europäischer werden müssen, ohne hierbei in einen Widerstreit zu einer notwendig weltweit ausgerichteten Internationalität zu geraten."

Having been a “compagnon de route” of EuroISME for the past 10 years, I cannot agree more dear Thomas!
Shall EuroISME be a forum for military ethics firmly grounded in “European values” or, pragmatically, shall we accept the fate of becoming a gentle hub open to free flow of all kind of interests and strategies?
I believe one way to address this question is by answering another one: do we have as our main goal to help European armed forces to reflect in a critical way on the ethical challenges the military is, and will be, facing?
Reading this written comment you lose the pleasure of hearing my Inspector Cluzo accent, but let me end with a question I asked myself while attending the 2011 first conference of EuroISME in Paris: do I formulate ethical questions the same way when I am not thinking in my mother tongue?
Today, EU’s Common Security and Defence Policy raises ethical issues less and less addressed by the 26 members of the European Defence Agency in their own Muttersprache/madrelingua/mateřský jazyk/anyanyelv/etc. Shall this be a concern?

All EuroISME members will agree with me in saying that if science is international, ethics is not? Is Europe braindead to the extent that we cannot anymore find in our own history, culture, humanist and democratic values enough material to feed a specific approach of military ethics worth to be promoted?

Quo vadis Euro(?)ISME…

PS: I express myself in a personal capacity, my views do not necessarily reflect those of the French MoD.[/justify]
Carl-M. Wilke replied the topic: #5 3 months 3 weeks ago
En tant que membre fondateur d'EuroISME, je voudrais profiter de cette occasion pour féliciter son 10e anniversaire. Je pense à l'événement fondateur à Paris avec beaucoup de joie et de gratitude. En particulier, l'échange d'idées en français, anglais et allemand a été un grand enrichissement.
Je suis heureux que ce forum se soit continuellement imposé. Je reconnais une évolution inquiétante : L'expansion mondiale des formats (contacts vers l'Amérique du Nord et du Sud, l'Océanie, etc.) dilue l'approche européenne. Avant d'aborder les problèmes des autres continents, il faut d'abord être certain de sa propre position. Et cela s'appelle l'Europe, comme le nom de l'entreprise. Cela doit d'abord inclure la Grande-Bretagne et les Pays-Bas, mais aussi la France et l'Allemagne. Quiconque ne connaît que très peu les cultures et les structures en Europe sait que beaucoup de coordination est encore nécessaire ici. Autrement dit : nous avons besoin des voix de la France, mais aussi de l'Espagne et des autres pays du sud de l'Europe. À ce stade, je suis entièrement d'accord avec le professeur Elßner dans le chapitre 3 de son discours inaugural. La difficulté et le temps que cela représente se constate également dans la coopération internationale au sein de l'UE.
Je vois un autre problème dans le fait que la discussion sur l'éthique militaire devient de plus en plus arbitraire et donc édulcorée. Dans le travail d'EuroISME, je ne vois aucune structure dans quelle direction la discussion devrait aller : conseiller la politique ? Conseiller les soldats ? Profil des membres de l'EuroISME ? Ce dernier peut être attrayant pour l'un ou l'autre. Nous avons toujours appelé cette tour d'ivoire académique le cartel des citations. En tant que tel, il n'a pas d'avenir à long terme.
Je souhaite à EuroISME un succès continu dans l'élaboration de l'éthique militaire en Europe.

We use cookies on our website. Some of them are essential for the operation of the site, while others help us to improve this site and the user experience. You can decide for yourself whether you want to allow cookies or not. Please note that if you reject them, you may not be able to use all the functionalities of the site.